In Wheel Time Podcast
In Wheel Time Podcast
Born and raised in Houston, Texas, the In Wheel Time Podcast is a 30-minute version of the In Wheel Time live automotive talk show simulcasting every Saturday from 9a-10aCT. The broadcast covers a wide variety of content that automotive enthusiast find interesting - including new car reviews and maintenance tips that can be found here.

Join Michael Marrs Saturday from 9a-10aCT.

For more information about In Wheel Time, visit: www.InWheelTime.com
Nov. 12, 2026

Stop Asking At The Barbecue What It’s Worth

Stop Asking At The Barbecue What It’s Worth
Stop Asking At The Barbecue What It’s Worth
In Wheel Time Podcast
Stop Asking At The Barbecue What It’s Worth

“How much is it worth?” sounds like a simple question until you need an answer you can defend. We sit down with Greg Riley of Riley Plays Cars to get brutally clear on how car appraisals actually work, what an appraisal can and cannot prove, and why a real valuation is more than a number pulled from a price guide. If you’ve got a classic car, a collector vehicle, or even a newer luxury car you’re trying to insure properly, this conversation will save you time, money, and regret.

We walk through the biggest reasons people request an automobile appraisal: personal curiosity, insurance coverage, estate and probate situations, and vehicle donations tied to tax deductions. Greg explains why donation appraisals can involve additional IRS paperwork and why you should never assume any appraisal will “stand up” if credentials and documentation are weak. We also talk about a reality most owners hate hearing: condition grading is strict, true “#1 cars” are rare, and driving your pride and joy usually means it isn’t a top-tier showpiece valuation.

Then we zoom out to the collector car market trends Greg is seeing right now. Demand is changing as generations shift, some pre-1970 vehicles are softening, and certain restomods with modern engines and comfort features are holding stronger than older garage-built combinations. We close with practical advice on how to hire the right appraiser, why no honest pro will price your car without inspecting it, and how to plan ahead so your heirs aren’t forced to sort out values during a stressful time.

If you found this helpful, subscribe for more automotive talk, share the episode with a fellow car owner, and leave a review so more people can find the show.

Be sure to subscribe for more In Wheel Time Car Talk!

---- -----
Want more In Wheel Time car talk any time?

Be sure to subscribe on your favorite podcast provider for the next episode of In Wheel Time Podcast and check out our multiplatform broadcast every Saturday, 9aCT simulcasting on YouTube, Facebook, Twitter, Twitch and InWheelTime.com.

In Wheel Time Podcast can be heard on you mobile device from providers such as:

Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music Podcast, Spotify, SiriusXM Podcast, iHeartRadio podcast, TuneIn + Alexa, Podcast Addict, Castro, Castbox, YouTube Podcast and more on your mobile device.

Follow InWheelTime.com for the latest updates!

Twitter: https://twitter.com/InWheelTime

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/inwheeltime/

https://www.youtube.com/inwheeltime

https://www.Facebook.com/InWheelTime

For more information about In Wheel Time Podcast, email us at

info@inwheeltime.com






InWheelTime.com/InWheelTimeCarTalk.com available on iHeartRadio, Facebook, Twitter, Twitch and most podcast providers.

00:00 - Welcome And Why Appraisals Matter

01:30 - The Real Reasons To Appraise

03:50 - Donations, Deductions, And IRS Paperwork

04:40 - Who Can Call Themselves An Appraiser

06:20 - How Greg Builds A Defensible Value

08:30 - Condition Grades And Hard Truths

10:25 - Estate Planning And Appraisal Shelf Life

13:10 - The Collector Car Market Is Shifting

15:20 - Why No One Can Price Your Car Sight Unseen

17:45 - Wrap Up Plus Events And What’s Next

Welcome And Why Appraisals Matter

Mike Marrs

From the Texas Gulf Coast, welcome to End Wheel Time. Cars, places, and people. Coming up on this episode, we're going to be talking with Greg Riley about auto appraisals. You've heard about them. Maybe kind of wondered, do you need one? Greg's going to help us walk through all that. So thanks for joining us. I'm Michael Mars, and now let's get over to Riley who plays the cars.

SPEAKER_02

Good morning, sir. Well, good morning, and thank you for the plug. I heard that. I appreciate it.

Mike Marrs

Well, uh, that's that's what you do. There you are. You're in the garage, you're out in the shop playing with cars, I'm quite sure.

SPEAKER_02

That's pretty much where if I'm if I'm not working, that's where you're gonna find me, is in the garage. Okay. I'm either either out here eating, okay, one of the two.

Mike Marrs

So, Greg, you've been working and playing with cars for years and and working on them, and you've got written a couple of books. So you've got a lot of background in it. But one thing that a lot of people hear about, particularly the tax season coming up, maybe might even be involved in that, but car appraisal. Like some people wonder do I need my car appraised? I've got a classic, I've got a 57 Chevy, I've got a 32 Ford, or I got a 62 Mercedes-Benz, or my wife has got uh uh a two-year-old Mercedes-Benz. And I want to know what it's worth for my curiosity, interest reason. So let's talk about uh

The Real Reasons To Appraise

Mike Marrs

car appraisals. Why let's start with why would somebody want to get their car appraisal?

SPEAKER_02

Uh I will first of all let me say one thing is uh to start with, is an appraisal basically is one person's opinion on a given day, right? And so you may see appraisals that that vary and all that, but we'll get into that in a minute. But there are various reasons why you might need an appraisal. And you touched on several of them. Uh, some of them are just curiosity. Okay, I've got a car or cars, and gee, what are what are they worth? What are they really worth? Or maybe you need it for insurance purposes, okay? Uh you want to insure them and uh you want to get the maximum value and you want to be reasonable. Um, and so you might need an appraisal for that. And then we get up to kind of the next level, which would be um, let's say that uh a family member has passed away and you're dealing with the probate court and potentially the IRS. Okay, well, that's kind of a different level of appraisal, and what they're gonna expect for you to provide is gonna be a little bit different. And then the other thing, too, is kind of the highest level, I guess, is sometimes people want to donate cars as assets to various different things. And then you need an appraisal for that, and then there's some government uh filing and forms and stuff that have to be done as well. So again, it's all the way from gee, I've got a car and I'd like to know what it's worth, to I have a legal reason that I need an appraisal that's gonna stand up in court or stand up to scrutiny.

Mike Marrs

Okay, which brings up, I mean, you you touched on one of them that I've often kind of wondered about. There's a lot of things, uh people saying donate your car, your unused car. Some people, some organizations rehab them and give them to needy people. Some of them I think they just sell them and use the cash. But there there are that gets into a play of why you would want an appraisal so that you get, I guess, fair value for your write-off on your taxes and things.

SPEAKER_02

Tax write-off is primarily the reason.

Mike Marrs

Okay, okay.

SPEAKER_02

And depending on, I mean, there's a lot of different ways you can donate a car, okay? Uh now, the law, the tax law, as I understand it, and I'm always real careful, I'm not a tax guy. I do not give people tax advice under any circumstances, but I will tell you what I believe to be true. Okay, if you donate a car to an organization, a 501c3 nonprofit or the other various

Donations, Deductions, And IRS Paperwork

SPEAKER_02

iterations of that, they are required to hold that asset for a minimum of three years before they can sell it. Okay. And so sometimes that impacts their uh willingness to take on the car or the asset or whatever. And that doesn't really affect you as the person that donated it. It's just something to be aware of going in. And if you're gonna donate it, you're gonna have to have a uh, I think it's 88 form 8873, I think it is from the IRS. Don't hold me to the form name. But there's a form that's gonna have to be signed by your appraiser, um, and they're gonna have to give over their information, their federal tax ID number, et cetera, et cetera. And um you'll have to have that to get that tax deduction. And uh, you know, and the other thing too, I want to touch on a little bit, and maybe I'm doing this out of order a little bit, but let's talk about what it means to be

Who Can Call Themselves An Appraiser

SPEAKER_02

an appraiser and who can be an appraiser, because I think that's very relevant to this, too. In the state of Texas, which is where I operate out of, and I'm only speaking for Texas, there is no licensing requirement of any kind for an automobile appraiser. Now, if you're an adjuster adjusting for insurance companies, that's a different thing than being an appraiser. They're dealing with, you know, repair costs and shops and insurance claims and all that. An appraiser only deals with the value of the car, okay? So anybody in the state of Texas legally can print a business card and tomorrow call themselves an automobile appraiser. Okay. We talked about appraisals that will stand up, though. Okay. So what the state of Texas says is that uh you have to have relevant experience and basically you have to prove what your credentials are. Okay. And so I, with every appraisal that I give, I give them a two-page letter that basically says, well, here's who Riley is, and this is how long he's been doing this, and this is why he is credentialed or able to give you an appraisal. And so um that is the way that I operate. There are also people that belong to these like appraisal services networks, and they basically are affiliated with somebody, typically out of state, and what they do is they use their name, they help them book jobs, and they use their forms and everything to report on. Okay. Um, like I said, what I do is a little different. I'm kind of a one-man band, I don't advertise, and I do a lot of private collections and things like that. So just know who you're hiring and make sure that they have credentials that will stand up for what you're trying to do and also will give you a reasonable

How Greg Builds A Defensible Value

SPEAKER_02

and fair value for your cars.

Mike Marrs

Okay. So there's a lot there to unpack.

SPEAKER_02

Yes.

Mike Marrs

I I'm going through my mind. So I've been in automotive journalism for over 25 years at different capacities. I don't feel like I would be qualified to sit down and look at somebody's uh 1968 Z28 Camaro and go through and tell them how much that's worth. I mean, I could tell them after I got through uh slobbering all over it, I could tell them, yeah, you know, 20,000, 50,000, I could give them some weird number. So I I think that what you said is very important just because somebody's been around cars in in some form or fashion, besides just watching them and building them. But even at that, that you you need to look and see what kind of qualifications they've got. Like I know you've written books, you've done appraisals, you've got a lot of background, you've got a lot of people.

SPEAKER_02

And I and I'll tell you how I got into it. Okay. It was really kind of simple. It happened almost by accident about 20 years ago. I had a very high-end car dealer contact me and said, you know, we know you, we've seen you at various shows and all that. And we have an out-of-state client that would like a vehicle inspected. And can you come over here and inspect it for him? And no affiliation with us. You deal with him, you give him your honest opinion, and you know, he'll buy the car or not. Okay. But that's kind of what started it. And I started getting calls asking me to go inspect vehicles, pre-purchase inspection. That's another thing than an appraisal, but that we we'll hit on that another time, okay? Yeah, I was gonna say. And uh from that came people wanting to know what it's worth, okay. And I do a lot of research. I mean, you've known me for a long time, Mike, and I'm kind of a nerd. I'm a nerd's nerd, right? And so when I give somebody an appraisal, I don't just say the car's worth $25,000. I give them all kinds of backup that justifies how I arrived at that. I belong to a service that allows me to look at uh all these classic car auction company comps. I can see what their results are. Um, I have value guides from multiple different sources, um, and then I do internet research. And basically what I do is, you know, I take all that and kind of stir it up into a big

Condition Grades And Hard Truths

SPEAKER_02

stew, and that's how I arrive at a value. Sometimes um, you know, um an appraiser will say, gee, that's a number one car, and the book says a number one car is worth $100,000, and your car is worth $100,000. Okay. That happens a lot, but that is not necessarily the case because there are very few true number one cars out there. A lot of people think their car is the best of the best. But if you really want to delve into it and look what the definition of a number one car is, that's essentially a show car that's never driven. Okay. So if you drive your classic, it ain't a number one car. I'm sorry, I hate to blur burst your bubble, but that's just the truth.

Mike Marrs

Yeah, but you gotta have you gotta have a mark to to mark you got to compare against, you know, if this was perfect. I mean, in the AI world now, I can see where somebody would create uh here's a number one car. Here's the definition, here's the pictures of it that AI can create. Okay, so now everybody's got something to compare against. You know, are you a number one car or a number two? Like you say, you drive yours, so it's not quite as good as this. And I would think that might actually make what you do a little bit easier to explain to people that here's what number one is. You've got a really good car, but it's not quite the number one.

SPEAKER_02

Well, and like I said, I you know, sometimes I I have to deliver bad news to people. I have to tell them things they do not necessarily want to hear. And that's unfortunate. But you know, if if you hire me or a guy like me, what you're what you're hiring me for is to give you the unvarnished truth, okay? You're not hiring me to blow smoke up your tailpipe, okay? That doesn't accomplish anything for anybody. And you know, that and that goes back to like if somebody passes away and you got to deal with your dad's car collection or something like that, and dad says it's worth a bunch of money, okay. And so I I would uh advise people if you're getting older and all that, even if you don't

Estate Planning And Appraisal Shelf Life

SPEAKER_02

get a high-end detailed appraisal, you know, hire somebody and find out what your stuff is worth and tell your heirs, make sure that they know that and that everybody's kind of make it easy for them, okay?

Mike Marrs

And uh save everybody a lot of aggravation because you know it can get really have to have everybody dealing with that kind of additional stress during a time like that.

SPEAKER_02

Well, and the other thing too is that that I find is that that's if people are going to get emotional and maybe a little bit unreasonable, that's gonna be when it's gonna happen because they're under a lot of stress, right?

Mike Marrs

Right.

SPEAKER_02

And so, you know, it it it's um it happens a lot, right? And then you have you know, child A fighting child B because one says it's worth X and the other says it's worth Y and all that, but you can you can bypass a lot of that. Now, that being said, if you pay if you pay for somebody uh for an appraisal today and you don't die for five years, okay, that is not necessarily going to be something that they can use five years from now, right? Because it's kind of has a shelf life because the value of this stuff goes up and down.

Mike Marrs

Exactly.

SPEAKER_02

But it at least you're kind of establishing a baseline for them and for yourselves, okay? And then so if they have to have it re-appraised, the appraiser has a starting point. He says, Okay, well, Joe looked at this car and he said the following things about it, and I'm gonna look at it again today. And is it better or worse? And what has the market done? Right. You know, these these these are people, you know, view these cars as assets. And I guess one of the reasons why um I I think I've been a good appraiser is because I don't get emotionally involved in the value of the stuff, right? As a matter of fact, you know, I I would prefer it was all dirt cheap than I could buy the coolest cars out there, right? But I don't get emotionally involved in the value of things, and a lot of people do, okay, because you know, uh grandpa spent a hundred thousand dollars on this car, and you're telling me it's only worth twenty thousand dollars today. I mean, that's the kind of news you have to deliver when you do appraisals, and sometimes people don't want to hear that.

Mike Marrs

Well, I think that that's that's a really good point about getting it done ahead of time or trying to keep up with it because you've got a grieving spouse there and and they're worried about money because the the income earner's gone. You know, how am I going to survive? And you've got to tell her that this $100,000 car is really only worth 20 out on the open market today. And you know, that's the kind of stress you want to kind of minimize if you can.

SPEAKER_02

Well, um, you know, it it when people's emotions run high, they don't always make the the best decisions, you know, uh about things. And you know, the the thing about all this is um, you know, do some advanced planning and and and help your your your spouse

The Collector Car Market Is Shifting

SPEAKER_02

and everybody out and and you know and stay on top of it. And the other point that I was gonna make is the market is evolving and changing rapidly right now, okay?

Mike Marrs

Absolutely, yes.

SPEAKER_02

Anything made before 1970, unless it is, I mean, like the the high-end muscle cars, you know, the the General Motors Coars, the LS, the Yinkos, uh, you know, some of the rare Mustangs and all that, all that stuff is dropping in value, okay, because the people that grew up with that stuff that bought those cars new were like my brother's age. He bought a new car in 1969 and he would be 80 this year, okay? So those people are all kind of aging out of the market. So a lot of cars are coming to market, and a lot of them that are coming to market are the more prosaic stuff, okay? You know, it's just kind of the ordinary, kind of cool stuff. I inherited grandma's uh, you know, four-door cutlass, and it's a really nice one, and we've kept it in the family all these years. But you know, now it's time to sell it because now the the person that inherited it is getting old, and those cars are getting hard to sell. And what's really um dropped in value is things like these rather what I call kind of ordinary street rods, it's a model A with a Chevy 350 in it, okay? Or some sort of a Buick coupe with uh if if uh if it's a resto mod car, if it has an LS engine, if it has a custom chassis, air conditioning, all the modern accoutrements, those cars are holding up pretty well. But the stuff that your you know, your your grandfather, your father built in his garage, and him and his buddies put up to go, they built it away. Mustang two rack and pinion in it, and they put a Chevy 350, and you know what that stuff is just not holding up in value. And it's just nothing's gonna happen. It's just gonna get cheaper and cheaper. If you want to sell one of those cars, now is the time. Okay, it's never gonna be worth any more than it is today.

Mike Marrs

Well, I'm and I'm hoping that some of them get down cheap enough I can afford to buy them and then kind of do what I want to do with them for a start instead of starting from scratch.

SPEAKER_02

I've seen some of that. I've seen some cars out there that I'm going, okay, well, that's some stuff I've always wanted to own, and now it's like it's within reach for the first time.

Mike Marrs

Absolutely, absolutely. So listen,

Why No One Can Price Your Car Sight Unseen

Mike Marrs

before we get closed up here, because uh running a little long, so when somebody wants an appraisal, I mean, they they're not they shouldn't expect to just walk up to you at the backyard barbecue and say, Hey, I got a 69 cutlass sitting out here, uh, it's a 442. You know, what do you think it's worth?

SPEAKER_02

I mean I absolutely will not do that under any circumstances. Okay, I get asked that all the time. Well, how much is my car worth? Well, first of all, if I don't see the car and I don't inspect the car, okay, uh the value can be, I mean, it can be a beautifully restored perfect car, and then it could be full of Bondo and the chassis could be rotten out from underneath it.

Mike Marrs

Exactly. The frames all rusty and yeah, right.

SPEAKER_02

You have no way of knowing. And the other thing, too, is is that I mean, there's millions of collector cars out there. And if anybody tells you that they have in their head, you know, what everything is worth in a given moment, well, they're just you know feeding you a line, okay? So I don't ever give a value in anything without seeing the car and without doing some research, okay? Because, you know, I mean, it's kind of like you know, going to a barbecue and asking your doctor, what's it going to cost to have my pancreas removed? You know what I'm saying? Right. I mean, that's kind of an extreme example, but it's kind of the same thing.

Mike Marrs

You know, but it is because the like you say, the market does change, the buyers change that causes the market to change. I remember, you know, 57 Chevy's uh they're getting that's another one that's getting pretty cheap when you start looking out there what's out there compared to what they were 20 years ago.

SPEAKER_02

I mean I sold a 57 Chevy about three weeks ago, four-door hardtop, highly optioned car, needed to be restored, and it sold for probably about 50% of what it would have been worth six or seven years ago. Yeah, a project project car, I'll admit it's a project car, but I mean it was money sitting there, and it brought about half what it would have brought a few years ago.

Mike Marrs

Yep, so things change. So if you're thinking about getting your car, you're wondering about your value, whether it be for tax reasons, insurance reasons, whatever reasons, there is a way to go to through it and to get hold of somebody like Riley Place Cars to get uh uh an appraisal, somebody that actually knows really what they're doing, besides somebody like me that just likes cars and uh and there's there's lots of if you look in the the car magazines or online, you there's a lot of appraisers out there.

SPEAKER_02

Just make sure you know who you're dealing with, ask them what their credentials are. And you know, it it's usually pretty obvious who the the guys that know what they're talking about versus the ones that don't.

Wrap Up Plus Events And What’s Next

Mike Marrs

All right, Greg Riley, Riley Plays Cars. Thank you so much uh for your time and talking to us about this. We've got lots of things that we want to talk about in the future, the more things can be hopefully after the spring, we're gonna talk about car auctions, titles, some of the other things that we've talked about offline.

SPEAKER_02

A lot of stuff we can talk about.

Mike Marrs

Absolutely, absolutely. Thank you, sir. I want to tell you have a great day.

SPEAKER_02

Thank you for having me. Appreciate it.

Mike Marrs

All right, we're going to take a quick break right now, and we will be right back after these quick words.

SPEAKER_00

It's that time again. Fire up those engines. Heroes and Hot Rods is rolling into Bassdrop for Veterans Day weekend. Friday night, cruise downtown. Saturday, 400 of the coolest rides in Texas, take over Main Street. Honor our veterans, enjoy local food and shopping, and help support local charities and scholarships. Presented by Craig's Jewelry and over 200 local sponsors, November 13th and 14th, downtown Bastrop. Don't miss it.

Mike Marrs

Cars, trucks, SUVs, motorsports, road trips, and the people who make the automotive world interesting. In Wheel Time is changing and we're expanding. We're bringing you more automotive stories, more interviews, more destinations, and more of what you may have missed. From Texas to the automotive world beyond, in wheel time is your place for automotive talk without the politics or the nonsense. Join us for the next generation of In Wheel Time Cars, trucks, and the people who love them.